![]() |
Hudson's Second Visit Akron, Ohio Date of Visit: 02/20/15 http://www.hudsonsrestaurant.com Been a long time since our first trip to Hudson’s. Things haven’t changed much. I still hear good things about the Hudson location but it seems like Fairlawn is still being run by folks split off from the home location with a culinary school education and not enough experience. The menu always sounds attractive but most of the dishes don’t get there.
Our server was nice and efficient and the place has held up well. We
ordered a couple of appetizers and three dishes. Buffalo chicken
pierogies had a fair buffalo filling and were served with a nice
thick ranch but the frying left the noodley exterior leathery and
shard inducing at the same time…less than successful. The duck
poutine was well flavored…nice beefy duck confit…but the fries
didn’t have enough bubble time and had no chance at texture. So
close, but again misses too distracting to suppress.
|
|
||
The entrees came with salads, and here Hudson’s has it worked out
from soup to nuts (so to speak). The Caesar is cold, crisp and well
seasoned. The chop salad is loaded with veggies and gorgonzola…all
topped with a gorgeous orange mimosa vinaigrette. That dressing is
awesome and stands up to the stinky cheese very well. |
We also tried the meatloaf, the old world bake and lemon basil
chicken. The chicken was really tasty with the spinach, artichoke
hearts, lemon butter, chevre, easily the best of the lot. But it came
with the same horribly oily and flavorless taters I remembered after
checking what we had tried the first time. Still nasty.
Things went downhill from there. The meatloaf is made from a not
very beefy or anything else tasting paste and doused in an overly
sweet sauce and served with more nasty taters. The onion straws
weren’t saving that. The old world bake held promise. Pasta, bacon,
spiced fontina, mozz, and parm cream, all topped with bread crumbs.
What I got was pasta set atop a shallow pool of over creamy and
under cheesy sauce and flashed under the salamander til the top half
of the pasta turned hard and crunchy. Trying to scoop up the sauce
couldn’t rehydrate the noodle making the whole Old World Bake seem
more due to the passage of years than a style. |
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
|
|
||
The menu always sounds delicious at Hudson’s but I have not yet
found it realized in the actual restaurant. Some good stuff here and
there but always soundly beaten down by the simple mistakes. Shoulda
just gotten soup this time, forgot the soups were pretty good. |
|
Change in Ranking | |||||
Original Score | Which Way? | New Score | Why For? | ||
C+ |
![]() |
D+ | Was Hoping First
Trip Was Due To Growing Pains But They've Grown Into Pain |
||
Finishing up some shopping and catching a
flick (True Grit…Sorry Cohen’s, the Original was better but Jeff
Bridges was something) we were in Fairlawn and planned to grab lunch
at a place recommended by my in-laws. Residing in the plaza where
the now defunct Lone Star Steak House used to be sits Hudson’s. What
we had heard was a thumbs up on the soup (particularly the lobster
bisque) and the burger. The layout of the space is similar to the
old steak house but the walls have a fresh coat and are adorned with
family pictures. It turns out the place is family owned. The
patriarch has owned Hudson’s in Hudson for the past four years and
this satellite is being run by his sons, both graduates of the
Culinary Institute of America. Our server shared a good bit of
information about the family although the way it was told it wasn’t
clear if the boys had made their bones or if they just wanted a
restaurant like Daddy. It turns out they have some experience under
some well regarded names (Paul Prudhomme/Melissa Kelly), but I am
not certain entirely how much time they put in. I’m not one to
begrudge people a leg up in the world, it’s just that some who
haven’t built it are often prone to squander it…I guess the proof is
in the pudding. |
![]() |
|
The server was attentive and on the ball, although she teetered on
over the top here and there.
There was no bisque on the menu today so we went with cups of the
broccoli cheese and the white pork chili. My mother-in-law was
right, the soups are top notch. One thing about these two, they are
not afraid to season, in a good way. Nice consistency, forward
flavors, better than most. The chili had a warm spice and was full
of interesting textures. The cheese soup had a nice balance between
the stock and cheese. We were off to a really good start. |
![]() Thick and Rich Broccoli Cheese |
![]() Unique and Delicious White Pork Chili |
![]() Less than Impressive Steak Salad |
For lunch we ordered a steak salad and a burger. The salad was one real disappointment for the day. Uninspired and underdressed, Steph essentially picked out all of the steak and left the rest. The steak was done as ordered but here the aforementioned seasoning fell short. The dressing “Hudson’s Brandy Balsamic” must cost them a great deal to make as it was non-existent on the greens. I ordered the burger with home fries. Get the burger, skip the home fries. Seriously, get the chips or the fries instead. The home fries were flaccid, greasy, and underwhelming in any flavor outside of the grease. I left them on the plate. Sad, as the fries on the salad and the chips from earlier were a dark developed brown. The burger was another story. It oozes. Mine came with Gorgonzola and bacon, Yeaa Pig, and the patty brought back that sense of seasoning that had been sorely missing in the past couple of bites. You have to eat it over the table because juices run like a good cheese steak from Pats. All in all, I’d say it was a good lunch with a couple of misses. Could be growing pains, might be endemic, only time will tell. |
|
Ratings | |||||||
![]() Food |
![]() Service |
![]() Ambiance |
![]() What's Best |
![]() What's Worst |
![]() Overall |
||
B | B | B | A | D | C+ | ||
Soup and Burger | Salad and Home Fries |